Title page for ETD etd-07212011-193416 ( Browse

Type of Document

Dissertation

Author

Benson, Allen C

URN

etd-07212011-193416

Title

RELATIONSHIP ANALYSIS OF IMAGE DESCRIPTIONS: AN ONTOLOGICAL, CONTENT ANALYTIC APPROACH

Degree

Doctor of Philosophy

Program

Library and Information Science

School

School of Information Sciences

Advisory Committee

Advisor Name	Title
Christinger Tomer	Committee Chair
Daqing He	Committee Member
Geoffrey C. Bowker	Committee Member
Scott E. Fahlman	Committee Member

Keywords

ontological analysis
natural language processing
knowledge base
ontology
image description
construction grammar
image
photograph
photograph description
Scone
content analysis
natural language understanding
relationships

Date of Defense

2011-06-23

Availability

unrestricted

Abstract

The relationships humans express when describing images have powerful, but poorly understood, effects on how visual information is represented, structured, and processed in information systems. This study evaluates the benefits and difficulties of using content analysis and ontological analysis as predictors of relationship instances and types occurring in image descriptions. A random sample of 36 documented reference transactions from the administrative files of the Pittsburgh Photographic Library is analyzed in light of three describing contexts: image searcher, curator, and cataloger.

Through the qualitative and quantitative assessment of image descriptions, the research leads to several key findings and contributions. The most important findings vindicate the claim that recognition, capture, and classification of relationship instances can be empirically grounded utilizing content analysis and ontological tools and methods. Evidence comes in successfully ascertaining and capturing in a Corpus the existence of 1,655 relationship instances. Further, the analysis finds evidence of relationship types and subtypes of relationships whose members share certain recognizable properties in common. The study also brings useful, new insights to the capture of background information surrounding events using situation-templates, introduces methods for formulating case relations and image attributes as binary predicates, and it offers a new, finer-grained definition of relationship. Contributions of this study include a corpus of relationship instances, an ontology of relationship types, and a methodological framework that provides significantly better results than earlier studies in the prediction of relationships (the architecture of which is depicted in Figure 22 on page 102).

There are a number of ways this research could be extended and corroborated. First, event analysis ought to be tied to a system of semantic frame analysis. Second, test the content analysis form against other texts, which will result in elaboration of the core ontology of relationship types. Third, expand image description analysis beyond the current domain to include image description in visual ethnography, art history and criticism, and photography practices. Fourth, test how inference engines reason over relationships in knowledge-based environments. Finally, to aid in the analysis of the meanings of relationships, more work is needed in formalizing the ontological concepts used in image descriptions.

Files

Filename		Size	Approximate Download Time (Hours:Minutes:Seconds)
Filename		Size	28.8 Modem	56K Modem	ISDN (64 Kb)	ISDN (128 Kb)	Higher-speed Access
	BensonAllenC_June_2011.pdf	4.29 Mb	00:19:51	00:10:12	00:08:55	00:04:27	00:00:22