Type of Document Dissertation Author Hausmann, Robert G.M. Author's Email Address bobhaus@pitt.edu URN etd-08172005-144859 Title ELABORATIVE AND CRITICAL DIALOG: TWO POTENTIALLY EFFECTIVE PROBLEM-SOLVING AND LEARNING INTERACTIONS Degree Doctor of Philosophy Program Psychology School School of Arts and Sciences Advisory Committee
Advisor Name Title Dr. Michelene T.H. Chi Committee Chair Dr. Christian D. Schunn Committee Member Dr. Jonathan W. Schooler Committee Member Dr. Kevin Crowley Committee Member Keywords
- human learning
- empirical study
- human problem solving
Date of Defense 2005-07-05 Availability unrestricted Abstract Recent research on learning individual monologs and collaborative problem solving suggests that students learn best when they are required to be active participants in interactive dialogs. However, some interactive dialogs are more conducive to learning than others. Two dialog patterns that seem to be effective in producing successful problem solving and deep learning are elaborative and critical interactions. The goal of the present study is to evaluate the relative impact of each dialog on learning and problem solving by experimentally manipulating the types of conversations in which dyads engage.
Undergraduate participants were randomly assigned to one of four conditions: a singleton control, a dyadic control, an elaborative dyad, or a critical dyad. The domain chosen for the experiment was a bridge optimization task in which individuals or dyads modified a simulated bridge, with the goal of making it as inexpensive as possible.
Both problem solving and learning from the simulation were assessed. Performance on the task included a combination of two factors: the quality of the design and the price. Overall learning was measured by the gain from pre- to posttest on isomorphic evaluations, and was further decomposed into text-explicit and inferential knowledge. The results suggest elaboration is easier to train and led to stronger problem solving and learning than the control condition, whereas the critical interactions were more difficult to instruct and led to problem solving and learning equal to the control condition.
Files
Filename Size Approximate Download Time (Hours:Minutes:Seconds)
28.8 Modem 56K Modem ISDN (64 Kb) ISDN (128 Kb) Higher-speed Access RGMHausmannETD2005.pdf 2.03 Mb 00:09:22 00:04:49 00:04:13 00:02:06 00:00:10 If you have questions or comments please send mail to ETD-Feedback.